Meet Chauncey Swan – Risk Taker.
Like so many other first-generation Iowans, Chauncey Swan was born in New York (1799), and while we don’t know a lot about his early years, records do show that he must have been politically active at an early age, as he was appointed by President Andrew Jackson to the job of postmaster (a political position, indeed) in Otisco, New York.
It’s obvious from his life story, that Chauncey was not only a good politician, but also a healthy risk-taker, one who would suddenly pull up stakes and go where the action is. And by the late 1830’s, as Chauncey was nearing age 40, that action centered in on this new western territory called Iowa, where golden opportunity awaited those who would be brave enough to grab for it.
Drawn by the prospect of wealth through lead mining, Chauncey, his wife Dolly, and his four children moved west to Dubuque, the center of Wisconsin Territory by 1837. Ever since Julien Dubuque settled here in 1788, the entire Catfish Creek region surrounding the Key City was known as The Dubuque Lead Mines.
Combine Chauncey’s success in mining (i.e. in a journal Swan writes on February 3, 1838, he finds a “fine discovery of lead ore”) with his persuasive personality, and by September, Swan is elected to the first territorial legislature (to be held in November in the new capital city of Burlington) representing Dubuque County.
It was there, on January 21, 1839, when Governor Robert Lucas issued the following legislative decree…
An Act to locate the Seat of Government of the Territory of Iowa … so soon as the place shall be selected, and the consent of the United States obtained, the commissioners shall proceed to lay out a town to be called “Iowa City.”
Ultimately, three commissioners were chosen to survey Johnson County, which at the time was centrally located in Iowa Territory, choosing the perfect location for this new capital city of Iowa. Those three men were:
Chauncey Swan, John Ronalds and Robert Ralston.
Here’s how the University of Iowa’s Biographical Dictionary (along with some added facts from other sources) explains what happened next…
In early 1839 the legislature voted to locate a permanent territorial capital in Johnson County. Swan was one of three commissioners chosen to locate the site for what would be called Iowa City. The legislature directed the commissioners to meet in Johnson County on May 1, but only Swan (escorted by local resident Frederick Irish) arrived that morning (John Gilbert’s trading house). At noon, Swan told the crowd gathered that at least two commissioners needed to be present or locating the capitol would be postponed. He suggested that if one more commissioner could be summoned before midnight, the process could continue. A local farmer (young Philip Clark mounted a horse) fetched John Ronalds from his home in Louisa County (a one-way distance of 35 miles!). In the official record, Swan reported that Ronalds arrived around 11:00 p.m. Local lore maintains, however, that Swan turned back the hands on his watch to ensure that Ronalds arrived before midnight.
In the following days (May 4, 1839), a spot along the Iowa River was chosen for the new capital. On May 7 the other two commissioners chose Swan Acting Commissioner of Public Buildings. The Acting Commissioner would be the most directly involved of the commissioners in overseeing the surveying and platting of Iowa City, the selling of city lots, and the hiring of an architect and building contractor for the capitol. He would also give the legislature progress reports.
In the summer of 1839 Swan moved with his family (from Dubuque) to Iowa City and immediately took up his responsibilities. The commissioners had procured surveyors to lay out the capital, and that summer Swan oversaw the surveys, chose the spot for Capitol Square, and arranged for maps to be made and distributed in preparation for the sale of lots, the receipts going toward the capitol’s construction. Swan coordinated the land sales, which began in August 1839, collected payments, and kept track of receipts.
Chauncey Swan – Father of Iowa City.
Iowa City historian, Irving Weber, wrote this about Chauncey and the new “City of Iowa”…
In all truth, Chauncey Swan, a persuasive man, comfortable with power and influence, had his hands in just about everything going on in this fledgling little community of Iowa City.
Politician and Postmaster 1839 – 1841.
As we mentioned earlier, Swan had served as postmaster (a political appointment) back home in New York before coming to Iowa. Now, once again, as Iowa City was taking shape, he was appointed as postmaster for Johnson County, this time by President Martin Van Buren.
Iowa City – The Stone Capitol: Large and In Charge 1840 – 1842.
According to an 1841 report to the Iowa legislature, as superintendent of public buildings in the new capital, Chauncey indicates that he paid John Ronalds $600 for the finest oak for the flooring of the building. Remember him? Ronalds was the ‘better-late-than-never’ arrival in the little town of Napoleon that fateful night (May 1, 1839) when only two of the three commissioners showed up to sign on, by state proclamation, as appointed surveyors of the then uncharted Johnson County.
In truth, as building superintendent, Chauncey contended with many setbacks. Arguably the biggest blow came only nine days after the cornerstone was laid (July 4, 1840). That’s when the architect and building contractor, John F. Rague, suddenly left the project, leaving Swan with the added responsibilities of hiring and paying workers, drawing up contracts, purchasing materials, and supervising day-to-day construction. Click here to read more about John F. Rague.
Whew. But wait. There’s more.
Perhaps, for Chauncey, the most frustrating part of all this was the state legislature’s lack of trust in him. In December 1839, the state asked for all copies of contracts and financial records. The following year, it sent investigators to evaluate the capitol’s progress and review Swan’s bookkeeping. While no inaccuracies were ever found and no accusations of mismanagement ever leveled against Swan, the legislature in January 1841 decided to divide his responsibilities, creating two positions: Territorial Agent, responsible for project finances; and Superintendent of Public Buildings, responsible for supervising the capitol’s construction. Governor Lucas appointed Chauncey as Superintendent of Public Buildings, a position he went on to hold until February of 1842.
Iowa City Businessman 1841 – 1849.
All the while Chauncey was working for the state building project, he also entered into several new business ventures in Iowa City…
Down By The Old Mill Stream 1843 – 1844.
In the spring of 1843, Chauncey organized a meeting, presided over by Judge G. Coleman, to consider building a dam on the Iowa River for a grist mill. The proposed location was north of Iowa City (near present-day Coralville), and as a result of that meeting, a stock-based company was formed: Iowa City Manufacturing Company, with Swan serving as president. Within a few weeks, the company purchased three acres of land for the mill and four miles of water rights, and began advertising in the Iowa Republican for wheat to grind in December of 1843.
Unfortunately, by 1844, the company had failed and it’s property put up for auction, with the demise probably due to the stiff competition brought on by Walter Terrell and his dam and mill, also built in 1843, but located closer to Iowa City and much easier accessed from the surrounding area via the Military Road, built in 1840.
The Swan Hotel 1841 – 1849.
Beginning around 1841, Chauncey and his wife, Dolly, were keepers of the eloquent inn and tavern called The Swan Hotel, located on the northeast corner of Jefferson and Capital Streets, with a commanding view of the Iowa River. The Swan played a major role in day-to-day life during the early days of Iowa City. Here’s just a few highlights that are recorded in Iowa City history…
June 1841 – The Steamboat Ripple arrives in town. A big dinner celebration with Captain Dan Jones, and author John B. Newhall takes place at The Swan.
May 1842 – Iowa historian, T.S. Parvin, in his diary, states… “Stopped at Swan’s, the only good tavern ever established in Iowa.”
January 1844 – Upon the election of Oliver Cock (Cox), from Burlington, as the first Grand Master of the Masons in Iowa, a big celebration is held at The Swan. Johnson County historian, Charles Aurner, also mentions in his writings that the Masons often visit The Swan and that he “partook of a dinner in his best style.”
Circa 1848 – Iowa City lawyers, John P. Cook and William H. Tuthill, in the bar of The Swan, wrote a parody song, “Ah, Hummer’s Bell.” The song poked fun of Rev. Michael Hummer, founding pastor of First Presbyterian Church of Iowa City (1841-1848), and his unsuccessful attempt at reclaiming the church’s bell as payment for his longtime services. Interestingly enough, Chauncey Swan played a big part in the beginnings of First Presbyterian, donating both land and money to build the church that lost their bell to the disgruntled pastor. Speaking of the tavern at The Swan, I find it interesting that the Swan’s had a bar in their inn, since Chauncey was a founding member of the Iowa City Sons of Temperance!
1840-1849 – The Swan served as the station stop for all stagecoach travel into Iowa City. Prior to the railroad coming to Iowa City in 1856, stagecoach service was the fastest way in and out of the capital city. All aboard at The Swan!
Sadly, things for the Swan household took a sudden turn for the worse when on February 11, 1847, Chauncey’ wife, Dolly, died. This devastating loss might explain Chauncey’s stepping away from The Swan, giving the operation over to his son, Charlie.
Cordelia Swan (1834-1839) – Iowa City’s first pioneer death & burial.
The loss of his wife, Dolly, in 1847 was not the first tragedy in Chauncey’s life. On September 19, 1839, the Swan’s five-year-old daughter Cordelia, died, becoming the first white settler to die in Iowa City, and the first burial in, what is today, Oakland Cemetery in Iowa City. The burial site had been largely forgotten until the Pilgrim Chapter of the DAR (Daughters of the American Revolution) placed a marker at the site in 1935. Since then, an even larger memorial has been placed on the gravesite, honoring Cordelia and her pre-mature death in 1839.
One More Swan Hotel Story.
Before we leave The Swan Hotel story, allow me to share one more remembrance, this time from Iowa City artist, George Yewell, who was traveling in May 1848 with a friend to New Orleans, and writes this account in his diary…
“Suddenly, I heard, ‘George Yewell! What are you doing here?’ It was Charley Swan, my old friend from Iowa City, spending a few weeks in New Orleans on business.”
Yewell goes on to say that his short stay in New Orleans became a delightful interlude as Charley Swan helped the two young men find lodging and light employment which left them time for sightseeing.
Go West, Old Man, Go West.
In 1849, perhaps in the same way that he was drawn to Iowa in search of lead, the 50-year-old Chauncey Swan suddenly decided to head west for California in search of gold. Gold Fever had exploded across the country and literally thousands of settlers were pulling up stakes, making their way westward in the hopes of striking it rich.
A true leader, Chauncey organized a troop of Iowa Citians, going by two names: the Iowa City Argonauts or the Sacramento Mining Company. By working together, the group was able to raise a decent amount of capital to purchase the needed supplies and traveled west together, making the journey much safer. The party left by wagon train on May 6th, 1849, and many of Chauncey’s letters back home to his new wife, Mary Bliss (Walker) Swan, tell us about the highs and lows of this long trek west. Irving Weber, Iowa City historian, tells us more…
In one letter (April 25, 1850), written after Swan arrived in San Francisco, Chauncey writes that “I cannot find a man here I know among 50,000 souls” and that “it is no place for me in this City.” In another letter (July 27, 1851) Chauncey writes that he was coming back as soon as “I can accumulate enough money to book passage home.”
Apparently, Chauncey stayed in California until the spring of 1852, suggesting in his letters that he did finally find some success and was planning to return to Iowa City by way of ship, traveling around South America to New York City.
Sadly, records show that Chauncey Swan took ill and died just as his ship was entering New York Harbor. His traveling comrades reported that he was promptly buried at sea.
Kudos to the amazing resources below for the many quotes, photographs, etc. used on this page.